New Primitive Weapon Rule

iveygun3

New Member
Joined
May 24, 2005
Messages
1,092
Location
KILN, MS
What does everyone think about bringing in the primitive guns pre-1900
even breech loaders. I'll bet some 45/70's are already on order or back ordered at least. :?:
 

gtk

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 15, 2004
Messages
19,791
Location
CO via MS
I would LOVE to have a 45/70 whelen :)

Personally, I think with the accuracy of modern day muzzleloaders, we completely omitted what muzzle-loading season was designed to do, and thats is to let the rut happen without a lot of hunters in the woods with high-powered rifles. Heck, you could hunt just about all season with a muzzle loader and still have about the same chance as you do with a .270 :)

I think we have so many deer now, muzzle loading is more like a "tradition" than a management need.
 

iveygun3

New Member
Joined
May 24, 2005
Messages
1,092
Location
KILN, MS
I've checked around and the little H&R single shots are only about $200.
Wal-mart is $199.95 special order only.
Dealers about $190, but pay shipping and tax Wally wins the price war.
Think I might get a Sharps Replica though with 32" barrel and load Black-Powder shells on at least a 400gr lead bullet
 

gtk

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Dec 15, 2004
Messages
19,791
Location
CO via MS
do these older guns actually shoot as well as these new inline muzzleloaders ?
 

iveygun3

New Member
Joined
May 24, 2005
Messages
1,092
Location
KILN, MS
IMO a properly loaded and tested in-line would out perform the older calibers. it all about proper loading and if one can be consistant everytime then performance will show. only good to using cartridge is weather
 

Forum statistics

Threads
21,120
Messages
194,155
Members
1,912
Latest member
Barbara Zietchick
Top